However, if you go to the Kelp restaurant link in the page and do it, you're more likely to get the avatar. I tried like 5 times the 'normal' way, got fed up and used the link. Managed to get the avatar on the first try. I don't know how that link is different, but it cracked whatever algorithm Neopets use for the Kelp avatar. Cubical sea fungus. Cinder block sea fungus. Giant green kelp.
| Swab bush | Budseed | Lightning fern | 
| Furry autumn bushes | Fire bush | Negg muncher | 
| Tami veggie plant | Plantmelon | Gurple bush | 
| Rubber plant | Orb plant | Kollie flower | 
| Furrn | Pineapple plant | Spiky bush | 
| Floating cactus flower | Ring vine | Spine vine | 
| Twisting vines | Tuskaninny plant | Bonsai chia | 
| Sword bush | Axe shrub | Bad seed | 
| Large thorn growth | Tactis | Illusens orb plant | 
| Faerie bean plant | Strange bulb | Mistletoe plant | 
| Cabbage plant | Potato plant | Raspberry bush | 
| Blackberry bush | Autumn blush | Mini pumpkin | 
| Rhubarb plant | Strawberry plant | Runner bean plant | 
| Curly vine | Ice shrub | Flame bulb | 
| Cheery plant | Plushie fungus | Cubical sea fungus | 
| Cinder block sea fungus | Giant green kelp | Giant red kelp | 
| Giant brown kelp | Magic crystalline kelp | Spongy algae | 

| Grey sea fern | Starry sea fern | Prismatic sea fern | 
| Shimmery seagrass | Darigan seaweed | Geraptiku fly trap | 

| Spherical shrub | Ice covered bush | Snow covered bush | 
Neopets Kelp Restaurant
| Rainbow anthurium | Rainbow carrot | Bamboo | 
| Piece of hedge | Asparagus garden | Cabbage garden | 
| Carrot garden | Marrow garden | Dark thorn vines |